Sensitivity. Nothing irks me as much as a violation of human rights.

Monday, April 03, 2006

Do you know this woman?

Image sourced from www.thehindu.com
She is Medha Patkar, founder of Narmada Bachao Andolan (NBA). If you came late, here's an ultra-quick background: Our government is building an obscenely humungous dam on Narmada and is destroying rainforests, submerging agricultural lands and above all displacing millions of rural and tribal people without a planned or visible rehabilitation programme. This is at a time when the world has realised that dams are environmentally bad for rivers and many developed nations are busy demolishing them. Sardar Sarovar Dam project in Narmada is badly planned, poorly executed and statistically atrocious project against which Medha Patkar has been waging war for more than a decade.

Hold on. This piece is not about the project in itself. It is about Patkar. Till last week, she was staging dharna in front of Prime Minister's office. Her demand: The central government should look into the lapses in rehabilitating the displaced millions. Result: except some verbal remarks, Dr. Singh did nothing else and after some days, since her coterie was becoming a traffic hazard, she was arrested and released in the evening.

Since then Medha Patkar has been on indefinite fast and it has reached fifth day now. Nobody, just nobody is paying any attention to her now. You and I know what will happen now. couple more days, her health will deteriorate. She will be arrested again on the grounds of attempted suicide, admitted to hospital, glucose injected and released again.

But nobody from the government will speak to her.

Because her methods of agitation is non-violent and it doesn't affect anyone's life. We can beg and plead with Hurriat Conference, Hijbul-e-Mujahideen, or ULFA. We can even agree to hold talks with them within or 'without' the framework of our constitution. We request them to participate in our democracy, that is stand in the elections and become our MLAs or MPs. We do all these because, they are called terrorists and they have killed thousands of innocent civilians and kidnapped our jawans, held the daughters of our ministers as hostages and bombed our temples and parliament. We have none of these to expect from Patkar . She is after all a middle aged woman who can't even feed her supporters.

Recently, when the DMK President Karunanidhi claimed that the rampant unemployment is breeding Naxalites, I flinched. I loathed the DMK supremo for encouraging terrorisism. It is not the lack of jobs that's driving these people to taking to arms. It is this callous attitude of our government driving them up the wall. You go
for the procession, conduct public meetings, write articles dripping with statistics, and go fasting. The powers-that-be doesn't even bat their eyelids. You kidnap one senior official or plant one bomb in a busy market area, the whole nation talks about you and your cause.

I'm not encouraging violence or extremism here. I'm deeply upset about what's happening to that good woman who has dedicated her entire life to the cause of millions of faceless people. If Narayana Murthy doesn't get a few acres of choking Bangalore, it becomes a cover story. Chidambaram announces Fringe-Benefit-Tax and the Economic Times goes berserk. Medha Patkar's fast-unto-death for a small hut for Bolarams of this world doesn't even figure between the ad-breaks of 24x7 channels.

It is not a good sign that we leave such people unattended. And do not think that what happens in a remote corner of Narmada will not impact you. Those million faceless people will invade your cities for a measly housemaid, rickshaw-walla, or coolie jobs. And then don't complain that the cities are being polluted by the illiterate.

Worse still, don't drive them out of streets when the American President or Bill Gates visit the cities.

5 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Very true and with you 100% on this.

Apart from 2 Oct and 31 Jan "Ahmisa" is a forgotten word in this country.

Sad! Sad! Sad!

Shame! Shame! Shame!

3 April 2006 at 08:41

 
Blogger R Girls said...

this state is quite pathetic. everything is commercialised. its a real shame on the system which in my view never seem to be changing even with the best intentions of goodwill hearts

3 April 2006 at 09:54

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Wonderfully expressed. Waht can we all do to wake up and take notice? How long we will lament and be a spectator? Who is going to mobilise us?

6 April 2006 at 03:44

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Sridhar
I find it quite annoying when people say i am 100% with you on this or who is going to mobilise us kind of dialogues. Are you part of Meda Padkar andholan? to be with you, or you are going to deliver people from ignorance. We all talk BIG and when it comes to action we have 100 excuses for not doing it, or we want a messiah to deliver us. I found this article of my friend very nice. Read it you will also agree with him. http://www.indiatogether.org/opinions/guest/ralla.htm.

-Niha

7 April 2006 at 04:45

 
Blogger D.Rajesh said...

You are wrong my friend, atleast on the fundamental aspect of your write up!

I do agree on your point that governments fawn on murderers like Maoists, Naxalites and anti nationals like Huriyat’ites whereas ignoring people who register protests through Gandhian methods.

But please note that NBA is not without supporters. It has got its own world of backers, many of them if I am not wrong are Europe and US based, those countries who all along have destroyed all their forests (US is an exception in this point), dammed their water and enjoyed the benefits and yet do not want others to do the same.

Coming to the protestors, imagine just this scenario of Tamilnadu state having a big perennial river with origins and sea outlets inside the state and trying to dam it for distribution. Imagine some body who doesn’t belong to the state starts protesting, however right it may be, and that too if the issue had been analyzed by no less than by the Indian Supreme Court and certain decisions made. I assure you that if the lead protestor were you, you would not return from TN alive if in case you dared to enter.

The problem with Medha Patkar’s protest is that it is being seen in a totally different context. It’s about deprivation of water, which is a fact for the most of the common population of India. So anything that is being remotely seen as an attempt to stop water distribution is straight jacketed as an attempt to interfere in their basic human rights. Added to this if this is done by some one not from their state, the correctness of the whole issue just gets washed away.

A protest by hunger strike is noble and there is no doubt about this. If it’s for something like reclaiming land for the landless, like the Boodan movement or protesting against a big mining project, the righteousness of the protest gets enhanced.

Unfortunately if it’s going to be perceived as an attempt to stop water to parched areas, you can expect the worst of the reaction from all the involved parties. Hence you see the strange sight of BJP and the Congress workers getting together and protesting against NBA.

Coming to Medha Patkar, her sincerity in taking up the cause of marginalized people always looked credible. At least this was the case a few years ago till she expressed her interest to contest the central elections. There is of course nothing wrong in this move except that she was insisting that she would contest on behalf of a secular non-communal party. I could quite remember the stress given by her in stating repeatedly that she was naturally anti-communal and went on to give the usual talk given by any of those plethoras of secularist that habit contemporary India. This was in the back drop of the last central elections where the battle lines were drawn between the so called communal BJP coalition and the so called Secular Congress coalition which in turn made a special emphasis on Narendra Modi who was supposed to be the only evil in India. This particular charge had to be repeated by any body that needs to be called as a secularist. Modi was the favorite whipping boy and anything that is connected with him was communal. Though I do not remember Medha Patkar stating anything explicitly against Narendra Modi she nevertheless fitted the bill of being a secular anti rich pro poor image and her interviews were extensively covered. No doubt, Medha Patkar’s leftist or should I say perceived anti right leanings started lending a color of a clear bias against the pet projects of BJP ruled states, Sardar Sarovar being the main one.

Of course the dam was started long before BJP had any significance and in fact so was Medha Patkar’s protests. But the whole thing got a different color once BJP was in the picture. So anything done by BJP was communal and needs to be protested against.

Many did this explicitly but Medha Patkar was quite implicit about this. This began to manifest in open quite clearly only after last central elections.

Nehru said about the dams as being temples of modern India, which actually is highly questionable and debatable due to the real values offered by big projects such as this. Even though being a temple analogy a self declared secularist like Medha Patkar who do not subscribe themselves to anything that can be remotely equated to Hinduism, still sees the Sardar Sarovar dam as a temple and that too getting built by a must be hated icon of fascist Hindutva, a project to be detested. The underlying point, which goes along with the protest to ensure rehabilitation, is that the BJP being communal and so a dam promoted by them becomes equally communal.

My analogy might not be hundred percent correct but the way things are going it looks like that.

Coming to the dams, if one is interested please read the book by David Pearce called the Dammed! David Pearce is one of the contributors to the highly respected journal new scientist on water related issues and he is quite credible enough. He asserts that the benefits are less for such huge dams when compared to the costs involved.

However when you see the a Hoover dam, you will see how places like Texas have prospered due to availability of plenty of water and electricity which essentially was a dry desert till the dam was built.

So there are indeed problems in dams. No doubt. So are the problems with cars, 16 million of them being produced in USA and a similar quantity in Europe every year with growing numbers in Japan, China, India and Korea, spewing venom into the environment!

Unfortunately we have to wait till we find an alternate to IC engines. Similar we have to get along with dams till we invent methods to very cheaply desalinate seawater and very cheaply produce power by controlled nuclear fusion.

A footnote is that the protesting leftists are no way innocent. Look at the disaster records of the Three Gorges project in China or the environmental record of Soviet Russia. They were worse and today these guys are talking about restraining technology! Nice joke indeed!

16 April 2006 at 17:12

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home